« Lynn Allen at SolidWorks World: Is it Glasnost? | Main | Autodesk Pushes Interdisciplinary Application »

February 11, 2008

Comments

Janice

Bloggers or journalists? It's all information; information that can lead to solutions. For top quality solutions, check out the McGraw Hill Construction Directory, where you can download cad details from their site. cad details

cad details

This is pretty old news.

samsung LN46A650

Hi!

I've found your message to be very useful, though the information is not new.
I'm your permanent reader now!

p.s. BTW, what happened to your site template? Or is it just my browser? :)

http://www.youtube.com/user/samsungln46a650

fcsuper

To me, it is an issue of expertise. If you are familiar with the topic (take the time to learn about it, or are in the profession or some how else involved), then the journalistic effort is useful to others. It doesn't matter if you are labelled a blogger, journalist or king of the hill.

So much of professional journalism (in my experience as someone spoon fed this stuff from birth) is that most just regurgitate what they've been told, often second - third - or fourth hand statements; or worse yet, basing an article on a "Press Release" ugh!

That said, Matt Lombard made some good distinctions between quick blogging and the writing of serious articles that appear in a blog (my interpretation of his comments).

matt

Al Dean wrote: "to be honest, its simple - don't like what you read.. don't read it anymore.."

I think that's what's happening. At the SW World press events I could only identify a couple of names I recognized, Roopinder, Mr. Orr, Rachael, and I think I saw Jeff Rowe.

Why don't I know more real journalists? I guess I'd have to answer that the bulk of CAD articles are largely irrelevant to me, so I stopped seeking them out.

Mainly out of sheer ignorance, I'd like to ask the question "who is your audience?" I can't figure it out. The last guy who wrote for end users was Joe Greco. I read his stuff. I can't identify any one else's stuff that I actually read.

Most CAD articles I read are about the business side of "the industry", which barely registers for users. These articles could possibly be of interest to resellers, investors, maybe CAD admins. But mostly not end users.

I believe the phrase you are looking for here is "untapped audience". And they are moving toward bloggers who aren't beholden to advertisements.

What I meant by the "it's just a job" comment was that the writing is the job for the pro journalist. CAD is the job for amateur bloggers.

Al Dean

strange, I read all this, and there are fair points on both sides.. the 'bloggers' (seriously, I hate that word, its ugly).. seem to think the press don't know what they're talking about or as matt puts it.. "its just a job".. the press seem a little scared...

to be honest, its simple - don't like what you read.. don't read it anymore..

Josh

Hi Roopinder, I'm really looking forward to your insight and wish I had more opportunities to talk with you at SWW. Great topic.

matt

Evan,

I think the real distinction here is between amateur and professional writers. Obviously professional writers can also blog, but as I said before, it's the same old stuff, different format.

I wouldn't even venture a guess as to what hole to put you in, here in a public blog comment.

The fact that you're even conscious of a term such as "chops" in relation to writing suggests you take it seriously, even competitively (since "chops" is a measure of quantifying talent), and in my mind excludes you from the amateur category, even though I have absolutely no idea how you actually make a living.

Evan Yares

Bloggers? Journalists? They seem like labels to me -- things you apply to people because you have some requirement to put them in a pigeonhole.

What label would you want to give me? Journalist? Blogger? Maybe something entirely different?

CAD vendors have never known what pigeonhole to put me in. Do they invite me to their press events? Do they not invite me? Do they blacklist me?

(Consider Autodesk as an example. They didn't invite me to their press event. Think it was intentional or an oversight?

It was easier in the past when I had a business card that had a title on it. PR folks can understand the title "technical editor," or "analyst."

Here's what matters to me: Do you have chops? Do you have integrity? Do you have perspective? Do you have passion? And will you speak up?


matt

Rachael,

The people that I have heard are out of business are the SolidMap people, the developers of the product that both Joel and I reviewed with such different conclusions.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)